Saturday, January 4, 2014

Episode 2 - Crazy girl "of color"


Welcome back! I trust that you've all survived winter storm Hercules. They should have called it Boreas or Chione. (A little nerd humour for you.)

I've decided to start with something close to home today. (More figurative 'home' than literal.)

I'm brown. You may have already gotten that from the name of my blog or my picture. The first thing you probably see when you meet me is that I am brown. That used to bother me. "Why can't you see me as a person? Why do you define me that way? I am more than just the colour of my skin!" That is correct. But I have decided not to let it get to me so much anymore. We are a visual people. Colour plays a huge part in our lives. I taught English to Kindergarteners in Taiwan, cute little 2 and 3 year olds who were still only starting to learn Chinese. One of the easiest ways to teach them, considering the language barrier, was through colour. Red is danger. Green is go. Blue team vs Orange team. Using colour makes it easier to classify things. Make them identifiable, without labeling them, per se. So, when I say that I'm brown I feel like I take ownership of the classification that is cast upon me anyway.

Something that I've noticed since moving here (to the USA), is that Americans use euphemisms for almost everything, especially racial labels, under the guise of being PC or politically correct. It bothers me because I have overcome a lot of racial prejudice, first growing up in South Africa and then living in Dubai and Taiwan (which are both stories for another day!). I just thought that things would be different once I came to the Land of the Free. Every person who has grown up in SA has experienced racial discrimination at some level at some point in their lives. Even if we didn't experience the stifling grip of Apartheid first hand, the effects were (and are) still rippling through. Something that has helped us a little to heal and grow into the smiling, happy people we are today, is that South Africans can laugh at themselves pretty easily. Not so with Americans, I'm afraid. Yes, America has had a rough and tragic history of its own. It seems to me like White America still feels guilty for what their ancestors did many, many moons ago, and this can only be reconciled by rewriting history and/or using overly-polite terms when talking to or about "people of color".

Oh man! That term drives me crazy! And it is constantly used to describe me, and any other person in the US who is not white. So, basically, everyone else. It was changed from 'minority' to sound more inclusive and less derogatory, but isn't that term still pointing out the racial disparities prevalent today? How is that different from the label of "Non-White" given to everyone who wasn't a White South African during Apartheid? Now before the hate-mail begins, I'm just trying to point out that sometimes we can try too hard to be polite and politically correct, but it isn't necessarily a positive thing.

When I was in SA, we had 4 classifications for race: Black, White, Coloured and Indian. If I say that here when talking about South Africa, people start to look a little nervous. Like, "you can't say that out loud." Why can't I? Coloured (in SA) refers to a specific ethnic group of people of complex mixed origins, who are neither Black nor White. Now, if I had said 'colored' (without the u) that would be a different story. Or would it? I've been doing some reading and found it interesting that while White America may be concerned by the word 'colored', Black America doesn't seem to mind it too much. I mean, the NAACP, which is the "National Association for the Advancement of Colored People", has not made a move to change their name.

So, I said Black America and I hope not to offend, but seeing as I have already opened up this Pandora's box of "my thoughts on racial terms in the US" let's just keep going, shall we? I have trouble calling a black person here African-American. I recently read a Facebook post that was going around that shared Bill Cosby's thoughts on the same subject and it turns out that he and I are in agreement. We don't say European-American for white people and I certainly wish that they didn't say Asian-American for anyone who has roots in any country east of India, either. I find myself talking about this quite often of late, and it appears that my black American friends don't call themselves African-American either. They have never been to Africa, do not speak an African language and have no idea of any of the African customs. I do. I am, literally, more African than they are.

If you ask me what I am, I say that I am South African. I never say I'm Indian unless I'm asked what my background is. And then I explain that five generations of my family have lived in SA and that there are many Indians in SA (the second largest population after India), but we are South African. If it is the place I was born and the only place I call home, why call myself anything else? Why claim to be from some place I have never been and know nothing about? Just to make it easy for somebody else?

Dear readers, I don't pretend to have all the answers. Writing this post has actually given me a lot more to ruminate upon. What I do know is that it doesn't really matter what other people call you to try and classify you - you decide what you're comfortable with. You need to take ownership of who you are and don't allow other people's labels to define you.

Trust me. Go out there and own it! You'll be all the happier for it.

-G

** Disclaimer - this post is made up primarily of the author's thoughts, feelings and opinions towards the above subject. It is not meant to offend or insult. It is, however, meant to create awareness and provoke discussion. Please feel free to share your thoughts, provided that they are not offensive or derogatory. **


12 comments:

  1. Interestingly enuf... In Germany..I'm the 'black guy' which has its advantages (sic)...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hah! That is interesting Salim. I have to admit, I am curious as to what some of those advantages may be.

      Delete
  2. I remember mentioning a coloured friend to a Canadian once and he looked horrified that I would use that word. It's funny that people think you should call yourself Indian when you're not. I have had a similar experience as you except I couldn't call myself an Emarati even though I was born in Dubai and lived there all my life because my parents are from India. Well written blog G, can't wait to see more.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thank you. And thank you so much for sharing your experience with me.

    ReplyDelete
  4. You hit the nail on the head, G! I am more African than Indian and have answered that, "But you're Indian, how can you be South African?" question over and over again!

    It seems almost annoying that you have to write a post like this in 2014...it seems so obvious that where you're from is where you're from, without having to justify or explain.

    Anyway...bah!

    Great post!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks P! It is a little annoying, but until it becomes something that we don't have to explain - it's up to us to create the awareness.

      Delete
  5. I on the other hand refer to myself as been black, even though I would be classed as coloured. Why you might ask, for many reasons.

    1. I like been different and it really annoys ignorant people. :)

    2. I am not white and trying to explain SA history to someone not South African can become annoying!

    Another reason is I cannot identify with the mentality and ignorance and confusion of "where do I fit in" that comes with been coloured.

    and BLAh BLAH BLAH...............

    Enjoying your blog G!

    All that is missing is some G TEA!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for sharing S! It's comforting knowing that I am not the only person who feels this way.

      Delete
  6. And I, as a white South African, get seriously irritated when I'm told that as a white I am not an African!!! Given that I don't even know how many generations back my family arrived here and that I was born in Zambia and have had my feet on African soil everyday of my life apart from 3 weeks of international travel... ok, now I'll get off MY soapbox ;)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No, this is great Lorraine! Thanks for commenting. I was really hoping to open this up to everyone and to spark a discussion about how ridiculous some of these antiquated labels are and how we're always put into some kind of box so that other people can make sense of who we are. You're white, I'm brown, yes. But it shouldn't matter because ultimately, we're both just South African. That's it. (Or that should be it but that's not how the world works, I'm afraid.)

      Delete
  7. No it isn't 'as the world operates' - it is as ignorance operates. You are doing a good job of educating as such with this blog. Keep it coming! When is your next post??

    ReplyDelete